TuTu Cute! Blue Ivy Carter, daughter of superstar couple Beyonce and Jay-Z, was dressed like a ballerina for an outing with her grandmother Tina Knowles at Opera Garnier Theater while her parents rehearsed for their concert at U Arena in Paris, France.

Blue Ivy Carter told off her grandmother for taking video inside the opulent theater in Paris on Wednesday night. Tina secretly took a video to show her Instagram followers what the inside of the theater looked like.

"I'm in Paris, France and I'm at the most beautiful theater I've ever seen in my life about to look at the ballet. It's a walk-in ballet, it's so cool," Tina said to the camera, before panning around the theater which, according to WENN.com, appears to be the opulent Palais Garnier.

But signs posted at the theater entrance forbids tourists from taking photos and video.

In the background, the gradeschooler can be heard reminding her grandma that taking video was against the venue's rules.

"You're not supposed to take videos grandma," Blue said sweetly. "You're not supposed to."

Beyonce and Jay Z also have 11-month-old twins, a daughter, Rumi, and a son, Sir Carter.

Photos by Best Image / BACKGRID

  • ShelbyMoore

    She's very cute. I'm so happy the parents are dressing her as a child and not an IG THOT.

  • Ms. Jackson

    She's a beauty!

  • iWasteTime

    She's such a little doll.
    Loving her little life!


    They not gone be able to take her when she gets older.

  • Tiff J

    How cute, just like a typical kid, lost in her own world, not having a care that she's being watched.

  • FukkFolks2018

    Blue Ivy is so cute. Garsh

  • SpillyNillie

    Blue is cute- a nice mix of mommy and daddy. Wonder what the twins look like...

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1lo6u-UIbo Nancy Drew-Natural & Luv’n It!
  • WutizstillHERE!

    She is blossoming into a beauty! Im so glad they are keeping her natural too! I love that they are allowing her to be a little girl! bravo to an old school grandma too!


    I don't care what yall say. Blue is cute.


    I know cause these modern day grandma's don't babysit or do nothing with the Grandbabies.

  • Renee26

    Blue is so pretty

  • Owww76

    Look at lil Shawn Carter Jr getting big & her witches of eastwick grandma.

  • Miss Lady

    You can see Miss Tina's age from that profile picture. She's snatched in the front but she needs to handle the sides. BIC has really grown into her looks, she cute...now. I like her little outfit. I wonder how my job would feel if I showed up in something similar.

  • Dove Amerie

    Tina's mupett profile...

  • Dove Amerie


  • Meme

    I'm telling you very pretty girl

  • king shun

    my daughter looks better

  • sunni_daze

    They dress her so appropriate for her age I love it. unlike others.

  • sunni_daze

    I figure we'll see them if/when the sales for this tour get slow or low. They gotta keep the aces in the back pocket.

  • Gloria

    I love that she is dressed appropriately. Like a child should be.
    She is the cute version of her dad lol

  • Faithz

    Blue is a Sweetie, and Ms Tina Feet look like she has danced harder than her "Shake Dancing Daughter" has ever Danced.

  • Rayne

    I love how they are raising her.

  • Logan Roberts

    I wonder did Richard Lawson really marry Tina for love or for money ?

  • disqus_DxKO3ThTGI


  • NeverSurprised

    And looking VERY sweet and innocent.

  • NeverSurprised

    Who said she wasn’t cute? She’s adorable.

  • Zedian Queen

    They actually charge to babysit their grand kids, yes BLACK people too smh

  • Readytochokemothernatureout

    Blue ? I wish folks would leave their faces alone.

  • disqus_DxKO3ThTGI

    Yup, Ms Tina has the official Gobble Neck or Old lady neck. From the way Gladys look to how some of these untouchable faces of older women, ummmm, I think I will be getn a lil face/neck lift if I need it Then again, once you pass that stage in your life- I guess they say...To hell with it- Love me or Leave me......lol

  • Readytochokemothernatureout
  • NeverSurprised

    I actually think Tina looks better here than in those ridiculous over-filtered videos and pics. At least she looks like an actual person here. The filtered video erased very human line in her face.

  • NeverSurprised

    Never thought this would actually happen, but since he no longer has the money to buy his way out of trouble, I guess this is a logical result.

  • Knocked Kneed and Pigeon Toed

    She's such a cutie!!! So glad they are letting her be a child.

  • ZRoJoTheLezBeyond

    Me, too. Gawd, she's gonna be so tall!

  • Readytochokemothernatureout

    It's about time.

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1lo6u-UIbo Nancy Drew-Natural & Luv’n It!


    (now watch his cowardly pasty azz go on suicide watch, smh)

  • Readytochokemothernatureout

    He might actually complete it. To go from rich to somebody's bish might be too murch..

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1lo6u-UIbo Nancy Drew-Natural & Luv’n It!

    right. he couldn't possibly handle being on the receiving end of what he's done to countless women. old bish!

  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1lo6u-UIbo Nancy Drew-Natural & Luv’n It!

    okay Sis, i'm about to jet. (and i see the yt trolls are out, so i am OUT)

  • Readytochokemothernatureout

    Ok Sis ttyl enjoy the rest of your day.

  • Readytochokemothernatureout


  • Miss Thang

    lol so petty

  • Dove Amerie

    Let's seeeee. hmmph

  • Dove Amerie

    lmao. Right!

  • Miss Thang

    I don't find this child particularly cute. She looks like a regular, well-cared for, kid. I do like her hair like this, and the outfit.

  • Chaseboogie The Prince

    Blue is starting to come into her own. That's nice to see. She is starting to look a little like Bey, but she def look like her dad. He has very strong genes.

  • thaye

    So I guess I’m the only one here to sniggle and giggle about the state of Tina’s newest face ?

  • TMW

    Botox all she wants, but the feet and hands don’t lie.

  • Dowoop

    No you are not.

  • Evelyn Lattimore

    Too much Jay-Z in her face. But i can see her blossoming into a beauty as she gets older.

  • OriginalGuestest

    I love how they dress Blue ! Shes so cute! Mama Tina looking errr bit of her age ?

  • Marlika

    Aww she’s so beautiful! ? she’s a balance of both of her parents.

    Tina is aging badly. She also needs to lay off the plastic surgery. ? Ol Matt tangled eye ass sure did a number on her self esteem.

  • SweetTEE

    Didnt even attempt to lotion them..?????

  • MsPam

    For money, besides Matthew and Richard were best friends and Tina was best friends with Richard’s sister!

  • MsPam

    You’re right but because she’s a child of celebrities she get a pass! Don’t @ me either!

  • hottlanta

    They suppose to. It is wrong to think that grandma ain't got nothing to do but keep your kids. My girlfriend moved clear across time to get away from her daughter and her kids. She thought she could drop them off anytime she wanted to. The last straw when she bought them over there on a Wednesday night to go to Las Vegas. Me and this guy got into an argument about that subject. He was mad because his wife mom said she wasn't gonna keep the kids and he was livid as if she was SUPPOSED to and she ain't doing nothing anyway. I told him why marry her and have kids if you can't afford day care. Your kids are your responsibility not hers. If she was dead you would find a way so man up and find a way. It is the right thing to do. I PAID my mom for keeping my kids while I worked so if we ever got into an argument she can't say she RAISED my kids. I made sure I did right by her.

  • Ebony Starr

    about to look at the ballet
    Tina knows that she is country, it's so endearing.

  • Faithz

    Smiling. Blue is Beyonce greatest Hit, and now if we can get a glance at them twins, before they finish high school.

  • Jaitlyn_Kenner

    Momma Tina, are those ankles okay?

  • Lorenzo Chaps

    Beyonce will reveal the twins when they turn a year old. Does Blu's tutor travel with them or she just do her ish online like a kid boss?

  • Ang

    Yep. You know she's waiting until she needs to advertise something or get headlines for something. She released pics of blue when she was promoting her documentary.

  • friendofblog

    LMAO! If you don't get out of my head...

  • Jussjess25

    I like blue shes a really smart kidd. But why do her parents put weave in her hair so early?? Seriously asking

  • hottlanta

    Did you see the tweets of Wendy Williams and her mom for Mother's Day. Folks had no chill. When someone said who in the hell ole leather suitcase is that talking about her mom's tan wrinkles I was done.

  • pecancandy

    Gal fluid retention is real, just wait youngin

  • pecancandy

    Well.....I didn’t know that. Cue “ who is making love to your ol lady while you were out makin love”

  • BlackFeeMale

    I can tell she being raised well rounded. Not cause she dont show public tantrums or the sort but its just somethin about her demeanor in her lil videos and photos. I like that she is around tina alot.

  • Tbay _

    Tina looking like the Grinch that stole Christmas.

  • Alextra Ballard

    Lmaooo...yew hit that nail right on the head...that side profile is horrid.

  • Alextra Ballard

    Blue is a cutie...all those nips and tucks Ms Tina had is no longer working.

  • sunni_daze

    See we all know how the game goes.

  • Libra80sBaby

    This baby is the PERFECT mixture of Bey and Jay. I mean PERFECT combo...BTW...why we aint seen the twins????

  • what?why

    Blue is soo-o-o cute and age appropriate behavior. What a beauty - good job Carters. Now Tina needs to lay off the plastic surgery - she looks scary in some pics. Love yourself Tina!

  • what?why

    The little we have seen of them - the boy looks like Beyonce and the girl is ????? maybe Blue.

  • BingBangBoom

    Grandma's face in that top pic.. Lol someone give her her readers please.

  • Jennifer

    It is amazing how Beyonce's genes broke through Jay Zs. I thought any child of his would be a spitting image. She's really cute! And really tall for 6! Kudos to Tina for being a REAL granny. She always had Jules too.

  • Ang

    Everyone who isn't determined to stan for her sees it.

  • Cats Gold

    Her hair is natural and long.

  • ImWoke

    She’s adorable, such a little lady.

  • Kimocha

    I wasn't gonna say anything but Tina does not look like herself in those pics.... her face is looking like it's kind of swollen....ijs

  • Daryl Campbell

    Tina has the old woman ankle syndrome

  • Chuck

    Ms. Tina’s natural beauty has left, due to the many facial procedures, Botox, etc. Her face looks scary. Lil Jay Z and Bey is pretty and dresses like a little girl. She is living the life!

  • Munchosgirl

    They were friends.....Richard has his own money, and is still working.

  • Munchosgirl

    I was thinking so they don't have to do it often....used to wonder why Tina put it in Solange and Beyonce head as well...

  • Munchosgirl

    Blue was enrolled in school...school is probably over for her.

  • MsPam

    Didn’t I say that?! Richard has money but he’s no where near filthy rich!

  • Munchosgirl

    No you didn't, you said they were best friends, they were friends...is Tina filthy rich?

  • MsSlayla

    this kids too big and tall for tutus. She out grown that look sorry

  • Jussjess25

    Good point