Duval twins

Alexandria Duval, whose twin sister died when the car they were in fell off a cliff in Hawaii, has been charged in her sister's death. Duval, a 38-year-old yoga instructor, was arrested Friday outside her home in Albany, NY, CBS News reports.

Duval tried to escape but the New York State police quickly apprehended her. She was booked into the Albany County jail where she awaits extradition back to Hawaii to face trial.

The bizarre case unfolded on May 29 in Hana, Hawaii, when Alexandria and Anastasia Duval got into a heated, hair pulling shouting match while driving on scenic Hana Highway.

Witnesses saw the two women fighting over the steering wheel of the Ford Explorer when they saw the vehicle accelerate before taking a sharp left over the cliff.

The car plunged 200 feet to the jagged rocks below and landed on the passenger side.

Anastasia, who was on the passenger side, died instantly. Alexandria survived her minor injuries.

A judge later dropped a murder charge against her due to insufficient evidence. She was released from jail and she returned to her home in upstate NY.

But the Maui prosecutor refused to close the case. They say Alexandria, also known as Alison Dadow, intentionally drove the car off the cliff.

A grand jury indicted Alexandria on second-degree murder last month and a warrant was issued for her arrest.

  • Dee

    She looks the part.

  • Salliemae’s Boosh

    I remember this story. But wouldn't she have killed herself to by driving off of the cliff? There's no way to have known how the car would have landed. I wonder what other evidence there is.

  • http://citygirlzen.blogspot.com/ missarewa

    New meaning to evil twin

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    What happened to the case where the lady was killed leaving gym class?

  • Str8tUpMenace

    Wonder if this will appear on the show, Evil Twins

  • stav

    Wouldn't they both look the same, I mean they were identical!

  • http://thedevereauxshow.com/ Ms.Devereaux

    Yes!!

  • n1kk1a

    How does one prove something like this? How fast were they going for others to see them fighting over the steering wheel? Don't you know you don't fight people while they're driving? So many questions...?

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    I got beans, greens, tomatoes, potatoes, rams, lamb.

  • Yoni

    WE MAAAAAAAAADDEEEEEEEEE IT! LMAO

    I always want to add "and some leftooooova pork chops" to that. LOL

  • harley_quinn2.0

    I don't understand why the filed murder charges back then and I don't understand now. How are you going to prove she intentionally drove off the cliff? They were both fighting in the car. She could've been dead too.

  • Irony

    Hogs, dogs, chicken, turkey, rabbit...

  • Buttercup

    LMBO. I've been watching that all weekend.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    This case was bizarre as hell. They moved away to Hawaii, changed their names to two OTHER "A" twin mames, and then one went "psycho killer Norman Bates" (in my Big Baby Jesus, Dirt McGirt voice). None of that has been answered. What was they running from?

  • Buttercup

    I hope so.

  • Yoni

    Any moon watchers/gazers out there? Don't forget to admire her pretty self tonight.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    I read they fought erryday ALL day

  • MISSMEWITDATBULL

    RIP, Big Baby Jesus!!!
    That's all I got.

  • Sucker Free

    2nd degree murder does not require intent only recklessness

  • Irony

    They were already involved in ish. Why aren't you making BIG moves in this good US of A? District Attorney? President? LOL

  • leapyearpisces

    This sounds like a lifetime movie. There was some lifetime movie where the twins were fighting in the car and the car went off the cliff (just like here) only the one twin was in a coma for a long time and anyway, the other twin made it seem like it was HER that was in a coma, and she took over the other twins life, but the daughter just felt that it was something fishy and that wasn't her mother...

  • Sucker Free

    The super moon ? I've been watching it all weekend

  • hotntot95

    How tragic...two Becky's are gone...?

    ...anyways...I was thinking..it's been 43 president's that never gave a dayum about us...we had one in ahalf that we could kinda identify with...I think I'm more dissapointed in actually believing this country was making progress away from racism...but it's gonna be OK because we are a strong group of people, I know I been thru alot and I can handle alot...hell just go back in history and remember Rosa Parks, Harriet Tubman, ..they endured the MOST..
    ...we will survive this..

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Yesterday was the anniversary of his death. Been listening to Dirt Dog all weekend. Hence me sneaking him in there lol.? God bless his soul. He was one of a kind.

  • Irony

    I feel like I saw this, but I'm not a Lifetime watcher.

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    Becky the scammers.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Leave my Caucasian house!

  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    *goes to google *

  • Yoni

    As have I. Was on the porch last night (cold asf) in my robe "gazing".

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    Saw it this morning. Breathtaking.

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    Cinn — About 1,000 protesters have marched through downtown Cincinnati after a mistrial was declared in the trial of a white police officer who fatally shot of an unarmed black motorist. Former University of Cincinnati police officer Ray Tensing was charged with murder after shooting Sam DuBose in the head after pulling him over. A prosecutor says the jury was leaning toward a lesser conviction of voluntary manslaughter but couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict.

    A mistrial was declared Saturday in the murder trial of former University of Cincinnati police Officer Ray Tensing in connection with the fatal July 2015 shooting of motorist Sam DuBose during a traffic stop.
    http://wgntv.com/2016/11/12/mistrial-of-white-cincinnatti-officer-who-fatally-shot-unarmed-black-man-draws-protests/

  • MISSMEWITDATBULL

    *switches off the new A Tribe Called Quest to cue up ODB*
    Didn't realize he died on my God baby's Bday...I'm bout to get my shimmy shimmy ya on in his honor before this conference call!

  • LibraGirlonly

    Here we go!

  • Yoni

    Yep.

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    Shoutout to all the folks protesting and shutting down highways and byways. ??????

  • LibraGirlonly

    ????????

  • SpiceGirl

    yup in my city.....

  • LibraGirlonly

    We need to show them our power by not spending our money!!!!!!!

  • LibraGirlonly

    We need to show them our power by not spending our money!!!!!!!

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    Out on 395 right now and Towson and Silver Spring

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    Out on 395 right now and Towson and Silver Spring

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Do Brooklyn Zoo! ??And if you don't get around to it today...his birthday would have been tomorrow. We got time!

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Do Brooklyn Zoo! ??And if you don't get around to it today...his birthday would have been tomorrow. We got time!

  • Yoni

    513 stand up!

  • Yoni

    513 stand up!

  • Irony

    I can't see shooting someone in the head as manslaughter! That's down-right REDRUM!

  • Irony

    I can't see shooting someone in the head as manslaughter! That's down-right REDRUM!

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    Agree with not 100 percent

    Rosa Parks, Harriet Tubman, ..they endured the MOST..
    ____________________
    Many of us have endured the "most"

    April 2014 Dontre Hamilton Milwaukee - was fatally shot 14 times by a police officer in a Milwaukee park. The officer was responding to a call from employees at a nearby Starbucks alleging that Hamilton, who had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, was disturbing the peace.

    Eric Garner -New York Eric Garner, 43, was killed after he was put in an illegal chokehold for 15 seconds by a white police officer — allegedly for selling loose cigarettes. Garner said “I can’t breathe” 11 times as he was held down by several officers on a sidewalk.
    The officer who put Garner in the chokehold, Daniel Pantaleo, was not charged.

    John Crawford, 22, was shot and killed by a police officer at a Walmart in Beavercreek, Ohio. There did not appear to be a confrontation with the police, and Crawford was unarmed — he had been holding a toy BB gun.
    The officers involved in the shooting, Sean Williams and David Darkow, were not charged.

    Unarmed Michael Brown, 18, was shot and killed by Ferguson police officer Darren Wilson.
    In November, a grand jury declined to charge Wilson in the fatal shooting. Brown’s death and the lack of charges against Wilson sparked protests, some of them violent, in Ferguson and across the nation.
    On March 4, the Department of Justice announced that it too would not charge Wilson for the shooting after an exhaustive investigation.

    Ezell Ford, a 25-year-old mentally ill man, was shot three times, including once in the back, by a white police officer. He was unarmed.
    The investigation is still ongoing, but it has been placed on an “investigative hold”. So far, no charges have been filed against Sharlton Wampler and Antonio Villegas, the two officers involved.

    Dante Parker, a 36-year-old father of five, died in police custody after being repeatedly stunned by a Taser in San Bernardino County.
    The local investigation is still ongoing, but the NAACP has called for the federal government to take over, according to the San Bernadino Sun.

    Tanisha Anderson, 37, died after officers in Cleveland allegedly slammed her head on the pavement while taking her into custody.
    Anderson’s family said she had bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.
    The investigation into the case remains ongoing, and no charges have been filed against the officers involved.

    This list is overwheling, I see where you going. We will be right. and we have run for office ourselves and not get caught up in the hype and money.

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    Agree with not 100 percent

    Rosa Parks, Harriet Tubman, ..they endured the MOST..
    ____________________
    Many of us have endured the "most"

    April 2014 Dontre Hamilton Milwaukee - was fatally shot 14 times by a police officer in a Milwaukee park. The officer was responding to a call from employees at a nearby Starbucks alleging that Hamilton, who had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, was disturbing the peace.

    Eric Garner -New York Eric Garner, 43, was killed after he was put in an illegal chokehold for 15 seconds by a white police officer — allegedly for selling loose cigarettes. Garner said “I can’t breathe” 11 times as he was held down by several officers on a sidewalk.
    The officer who put Garner in the chokehold, Daniel Pantaleo, was not charged.

    John Crawford, 22, was shot and killed by a police officer at a Walmart in Beavercreek, Ohio. There did not appear to be a confrontation with the police, and Crawford was unarmed — he had been holding a toy BB gun.
    The officers involved in the shooting, Sean Williams and David Darkow, were not charged.

    Unarmed Michael Brown, 18, was shot and killed by Ferguson police officer Darren Wilson.
    In November, a grand jury declined to charge Wilson in the fatal shooting. Brown’s death and the lack of charges against Wilson sparked protests, some of them violent, in Ferguson and across the nation.
    On March 4, the Department of Justice announced that it too would not charge Wilson for the shooting after an exhaustive investigation.

    Ezell Ford, a 25-year-old mentally ill man, was shot three times, including once in the back, by a white police officer. He was unarmed.
    The investigation is still ongoing, but it has been placed on an “investigative hold”. So far, no charges have been filed against Sharlton Wampler and Antonio Villegas, the two officers involved.

    Dante Parker, a 36-year-old father of five, died in police custody after being repeatedly stunned by a Taser in San Bernardino County.
    The local investigation is still ongoing, but the NAACP has called for the federal government to take over, according to the San Bernadino Sun.

    Tanisha Anderson, 37, died after officers in Cleveland allegedly slammed her head on the pavement while taking her into custody.
    Anderson’s family said she had bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.
    The investigation into the case remains ongoing, and no charges have been filed against the officers involved.

    This list is overwheling, I see where you going. We will be right. and we have run for office ourselves and not get caught up in the hype and money.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Like I said this morning.

    Dew it. Dew it

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Like I said this morning.

    Dew it. Dew it

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    What going on Ret now Love?

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    What going on Ret now Love?

  • SpiceGirl

    this chick crazy!

  • SpiceGirl

    this chick crazy!

  • mzwhang90210

    But that's an odd way of killing someone. It's like trying to poison somebody with a bottle of wine..& sitting down drinking it with them.
    Anyway...did yall talk about Apollo supposedly being engaged?
    RHOA is supposed to air something about it later in the season ?

  • mzwhang90210

    But that's an odd way of killing someone. It's like trying to poison somebody with a bottle of wine..& sitting down drinking it with them.
    Anyway...did yall talk about Apollo supposedly being engaged?
    RHOA is supposed to air something about it later in the season ?

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    They out there protesting and shutting down the highway heard on 93.9.

  • mzwhang90210

    I gazed last night. AWESOME?

  • Incog-knee-gress

    If I grab your hand and jump off the cliff, you fighting me prior and during and was like bish DEW it if ya bad, and you do...who is responsible?

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    Good Day Dr. Whang - Talking about it below.

  • Vonn

    The sister that died could have stepped on the gas and grabbed the wheel. I can't wait to see how they prove the surviving sister's guilt.

  • mzwhang90210

    ?thankie

  • mzwhang90210

    ?...

  • Buttercup

    The prosecution will NEVER ask for the persecution of their own. Remember that.
    ========
    Umph

  • hotntot95

    Yes yes yes...I'm just now working thru my anger and disappointment ....we have to believe that we will be OK...I honestly and sincerely hope u have a blessed day ??

  • Jones

    That's what I was thinking as well.

  • Vonn

    I think they had a failed business & owed folks money.

  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    Yup!!

  • Salliemae’s Boosh

    that clip is hilarious!

  • LibraGirlonly

    "Major newspapers normalize Trump's selection of white nationalists as Cheif of Staff" !!! This is for all you black people that voted for Trump. Do you even understand what a white nationalist is ? The KKK.

  • Zeta Phi Beta 1920

    This case is..............weird.
    Let us say, she did drive off the cliff INTENTIONALLY. Suicide is punishable by law? And it sounds like the gas pedal could have been stepped on accidentally, due to the fight.

  • Yoni

    bish DEW it if ya bad
    _____________________
    LMAOOOOOOOO

  • CapricornIce

    These some ugly hard faced 50 yr. old twins.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    I said that same shyt this morning. It's same as white supremacist to ME. Idgaf how many minorities he supposedly switched it up and appointed them AS WELL. He put a Klansman hood wearing fukka in a real high position this weekend. No bueno to me.

  • Yoni

    Wasn't it?

  • Low E. TUH!

    HOOK IT UP, HOOK IT UP!!!

  • Salliemae’s Boosh

    that movie was good. Kyle from real housewives was in it.

  • LibraGirlonly

    Exactly!!

  • L.T.L. Since 2007

    God bless the dead....

    BUT them 2 'chicks' up top look like what Caitlyn was going for.

    #transJenners

  • Sucker Free

    What clip...was Rickey smiley talking about this earlier?

  • iWasteTime

    But if they both died it would have been a regular shemular accident.

    Dream has a IG page?

  • Incog-knee-gress

    One doesn't negate the other. This dude Bannon is a known Anti Semite. No thanks.

  • Renee26

    Intentionally tried to kill them both (she gave no fucs and went off the cliff....crazy

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    You too hun

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Breitbart News executive Steve Bannon‘s appointment as President-elect Donald Trump‘s chief strategist in the White House should be taken as a frightening development, a former Breitbart spokesman says.

    “Everyone should be terrified of that prospect,” says Kurt Bardella. “No matter what the official title is going to be, he’s going to be prominent in advising the president-elect.”

    Before taking a leave from Breitbart to become the chief executive of Trump’s campaign, Bannon boasted of turning Breitbart into the “platform of the alt-right,” a movement that pushes a white-supremacist philosophy. Under Bannon, Breitbart has included a section called “black crime,” equated feminism with cancer, attacked companies that employ legal immigrants, and described Weekly Standard editor Bill Kristol as a “renegade Jew” for opposing Trump’s candidacy.

  • LibraGirlonly

    Wow, and he looks very unkept.

  • L.T.L. Since 2007

    you fighting me prior and during and was like bish DEW it if ya bad, and you do
    ______________________

    This exact scenario done got me plenty of ass whoopings as a kid, because of my fat ass cousin.

    Don't tell me to do it, then go snitch. #FatPunk

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Extra! White trash-esque.

  • Renee26

    Second degree would work...she was fighting behind the wheel and witnesses saw the fight.

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    It's so said, he can't make white CEO build factories in the US. If he is able to do it. Those type of things take years and years to put together.

    Then it's the subdies they are expecting, "Tax Breaks" then folks want to be paid a genrous amount of money.

    He a liar and speaking about a plan he doensn't even have in place, at at least he show damn didn't discuss it on the when he was at all the Klan rallies.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    This! Why I whooped the piss outta my cousin as an adult. Bish all the whoopings you done got me from 5-16? You gonna catch these fists tonight hoe!

  • leapyearpisces

    Yes! Ok, I had to look it up, because I hate not remembering stuff. It was called Deadly Sibling Rivalry with Charisma Carpenter.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Yes. First pic she posted was her on her mammy teet. She got a Twitter too.

    So does Heiress Harris. An IG

  • Renee26

    I see people digging in their noses behind the wheel every day....we look. I'm assuming the witnesses probably were scared driving on that road watching the car go by with hair pulling going on and whatnot...Everybody could have been killed

  • SpiceGirl

    raising hand.....woot woot

  • Nataliegaye

    38???

  • Mrs Mary

    I thought both sister's were found dead get the story straight please

  • Renee26

    This....at the least she could have been charged with manslaughter but since she was actively fighting it's 2nd degree...she knew the danger involved

  • Salliemae’s Boosh

    it's a clip of Shirley Caesar signing and the caption is about what are you having for thanksgiving dinner. it's all on ig. Check your explore page. Super funny!

  • Renee26

    That's what the defense will argue

  • Buttercup

    :crying1:

  • Yoni

    And Ace Tucker..

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe
  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    Kandi and Todd too

    Ace got a line of clothing

  • <—Doesn'tTalkToStrangers

    All she needs is a good lawyer and that one witness might help her :shrug:

  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    Off topic

    Gwen Ifill died!!

  • <—Doesn'tTalkToStrangers

    Oh chitt ??????

  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    Bwaaaaaa

  • Jussie-JustLooking4Peace

    Great minds post alike

  • <—Doesn'tTalkToStrangers

    Both!

  • Yoni

    *raising fist* LOL

  • <—Doesn'tTalkToStrangers

    Watttttt

  • Renee26

    Caught it during sunset yesterday...Beautiful..my son says "you know the sky looks like that because of smog and pollution" ...I said well thank God for smog because the view is amazing lol

  • Incog-knee-gress

    And lil ChanelT. I actually think Coco and Ice started all of this. Celeb babies with an IG. It's cute tho to me.

  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    Yes cancer has been in an hospice. Didn't know

  • <—Doesn'tTalkToStrangers

    I didn't know that either.

  • Blue

    This has Lifetime Movie written all over it.

  • Incog-knee-gress

    Say what?

    *goes to NABJ site to see what they saying*

    RIP to her. Loved her

  • nicelyput32

    Rest in Peace..

  • L.T.L. Since 2007
  • Sucker Free

    I'm not on IG ?

  • Incog-knee-gress

    I don't think anyone did. So SAD. Damn!

  • harley_quinn2.0

    What!!!!! I loved her. R.I.P

  • Alicia.Ashe

    Oh no !!!!!

  • SpiceGirl

    lol....Hey you....

  • https://www.etsy.com/shop/AMarieNaturals Lovezoe

    So sad.

  • Salliemae’s Boosh
  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    Y'all we got a new post but it's a trump post soooo

  • Low E. TUH!

    I POPPED ONE OF THE LOWS FOR TRYNA SEND ANOTHER ONE OUT...IDK WHERE YOU LEARNED IT, BUT IT AIN'T FLYING AROUND HERE!

  • E-VannaRootsAllEvil

    No and I was wondering where she was doing this last election. She did such a great job as a moderator

  • Sucker Free

    So silly ?

  • mela.reign77

    I agree.

  • mela.reign77

    I just saw that.

  • Yoni

    Heeeyyyy!!!!

  • Yoni

    Tell sonson that the moon SHINED thru! LOL

  • mela.reign77

    The entire story is kind of odd to me. From what witnesses were saying the other sister was fighter the sister that's still alive. Who knows how that plays out. Unless she was trying to kill them both I very seriously doubt that the crash was intentional. I think they got into an argument and she lost control, plain and simple.

  • Renee26

    If somebody were to hit me while I'm driving I would pull over then commence to whooping dat ass....not keep on driving down the road. She had a disregard for other lives on the road as well....she should be charged with something

  • Renee26

    He said it looked like a sticker sitting up there lol....it was stunning

  • PRPSP

    i remember the time my sister stabbed me with a metal fork in my thigh because i told her that Boyz to Men sang better than Color Me Badd! I still have the scar....

  • Shani

    ...."eat you a bowl of cereal..."

  • Shani

    shame on a nigga who try to run game on a nigga wu buckwild with the trigger

  • Bam Bam Li

    It's so cloudy in London I can't see anything. Depressed me since I loved the moon ??

  • TDK

    She probably was trying to kill her self and her sister. Murder/suicide. The deceased twin probably was trying to keep her from doing it.

  • JerseyMom

    How do they know who was the aggressor? Blank stare.

    With a good lawyer, she can beat the charges.

  • JerseyMom

    How do they know who was the aggressor? Blank stare.

    With a good lawyer, she can beat the charges.

  • JerseyMom

    Blank stare.

  • JerseyMom

    Blank stare.

  • OkWhatevah

    You would think. But it may happen more often than we think. About a month ago, I just happened to look over, and a man was shouting at a woman (he was driving) , I looked away for a minute, then looked back. Right then, I saw him PUNCH her dead in the side of the face. First time I'd ever seen anything like that.
    Thing is, after that they were riding like nothing had happened. Had I not looked right then I would have missed it. We may be missing an eyefull sometimes.

  • jade

    Just because they were fighting doesn't mean second degree will work. The prosecutor has to prove that she intended to kill her sister.

  • ATL White Guy

    Do we really know who killed who? Did they do a DNA test? Maybe Anastasia killed Alexandria and just assumed her identity.....hmm....Lifetime movie?

  • ATL White Guy

    Do we really know who killed who? Did they do a DNA test? Maybe Anastasia killed Alexandria and just assumed her identity.....hmm....Lifetime movie?

  • ATL White Guy

    Do we really know who killed who? Did they do a DNA test? Maybe Anastasia killed Alexandria and just assumed her identity.....hmm....Lifetime movie?

  • Sucker Free

    Aww...there are pics online from around the ?

  • brooklyn23

    Dead
    No pun intended

  • brooklyn23

    True that. They are bugging out.

  • Naomi

    They actually made a Lifetime movie EXTREMELY similar to this a few years ago, but the twin acted like her sister so she could be her niece's mother instead of aunt. It was weird lol

  • Pamela

    DNA analysis won't help since they are twins. Their DNA is an exact match

  • Intellectual by Nature!

    Kill yourself with someone else in the car, though?

  • TDK

    Why would the car matter if both were dead?

  • Intellectual by Nature!

    Lol. Did your comment initially say murder/suicide, or was it updated? I initally read it as kill herself, my apologies

  • Lisa daniels

    Its gorgeous

  • Lisa daniels

    I think i remember that movie

  • Lisa daniels

    She shole is. Good movie

  • Lisa daniels

    Crackles

  • DeeFromLA

    The baby? Stop it

  • NYTimes#1Bestseller

    Again???? Damn, lock this bitcch up and throw away the key!

  • Shira Harding-James

    No this one has a smug "Marsha Marsha Marsha"!

  • Shira Harding-James

    I wonder why she would do that?

  • Yoni

    So beautiful! I couldn't take my eyes off of it this morning on the drive in. I don't know HOW or when or why I've been so moonstruck. I mean I LOVE IT!

  • Blue

    lol

  • LadyFrance

    Unless she jumped out before it went over the cliff. I don't remember the details of the story other than they both were a fry short of a happy meal from the time they were growing up. They had obsessed competitions throughout life with each other and very crazy tempers

  • Renee26

    No intent is needed....this here clause explains it for you: 2nd degree murder CLAUSE 2: a killing caused by dangerous conduct and the offender's obvious lack of concern for human life..........Fighting behind the wheel of a moving vehicle and driving off a cliff meets those requirements

  • Renee26

    No intent is needed....this here clause explains it for you: 2nd degree murder CLAUSE 2: a killing caused by dangerous conduct and the offender's obvious lack of concern for human life..........Fighting behind the wheel of a moving vehicle and driving off a cliff meets those requirements

  • jade

    Not sure which jurisdiction you copied that from but second degree murder in Hawaii requires intent. Also, the deceased sister could have been the cause of the crash if she started fighting the driver while the driver was driving.

  • JJ5

    I was thinking the same thing.

  • NovemberFling

    She still could've maliciously driven off the cliff with the intention of killing herself and her sister; however, fate had a different plan, in which she survived.

  • Felicia Kelley

    Have you ever been to Maui? I have, and have driven on that small stretch of highway.. One lane on each side.. That is NOT the type of highyway you get in to a physical fight over the steering wheel.. Just because you can't prove something, doesn't make it less true..

  • Felicia Kelley

    And she changed her identity afterwards as well..

  • Felicia Kelley

    Not necessarily

  • Felicia Kelley

    Just like when a robbery of a bank is committed, and if a homicide takes place, regardless if the thief pulled the trigger or not. They're charged with that murder..

  • jade

    Sadly, if you can't prove something in court, IT DIDN'T HAPPEN.

  • jade

    What you are referring to here is felony murder ... completely different concept from second degree murder.

  • Tea??

    Wow

  • Shira Harding-James

    My thoughts also!

  • Felicia Kelley

    I guess all those cops killing Blackmen on camera didn't happen??

    See, That is how ridiculous you sound..

    You new niggers kill me..

    Pay attention to history MS UNEDUCATED!!

  • Felicia Kelley

    Dummy, manslaughter is a felony!!

    Go educate yourself PLEASE..

    And pick up a DICKTIONARY, while your at it.?

  • Joe

    What happened to speedy trial from the first arrest??? I suspect her attorney made a procedural faux pas by not filing a notice of expiration of speedy trial after the first arrest...